Annie and Hailey welcome Dr. Irene Alexander, associate professor of moral theology at the University of Dallas, wife, and mother of six. Together they explore one of the most difficult questions in Catholic bioethics: what to do with the thousands of frozen embryos left behind by IVF. They also speak with compassion to the women and couples carrying the cross of infertility.
Dr. Alexander’s background
Dr. Alexander holds her MA and PhD from Ave Maria University. She teaches moral theology, bioethics, Christian marriage, scripture, and tradition. Her scholarship has appeared in the National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly, the Linacre Quarterly, and other journals. Her forthcoming book, Frozen Embryos: A Catholic Moral Evaluation of Embryo Adoption, Cryopreservation, Rehydration, and Artificial Wounds, is expected in 2027.
In this episode
- How Dr. Alexander balances motherhood and academic work, and why her family life and her theological work enrich each other
- A plain-language explanation of how IVF works, including the creation of multiple embryos, selective reduction, and cryopreservation
- Why the Church opposes IVF: it is contrary to the dignity of the child and to the unity of marriage, which joins the unitive and procreative meanings of the conjugal act
- The Church’s teaching as an interpretation of natural law rather than a rule only for Catholics
- Restorative reproductive medicine and NaProTechnology: ethical options that seek to diagnose and heal the underlying causes of infertilityThe cultural tendency to treat fertility as a problem to be suppressed rather than a gift
- Embryo adoption: what Dignitas Personae (2008, paragraph 19) says, the ongoing scholarly debate, and Dr. Alexander’s own position
- Artificial wombs and ectogenesis, and the ethical concerns they raise
Faith and courage in motherhood, including Dr. Alexander’s “pickle jar” story - Encouragement for women facing infertility and for those overwhelmed by pregnancy: God sees the ache and invites us to surrender it to him
A note on the discussion
Dr. Alexander is clear about the difference between what the Church has officially taught and her own scholarly argument. Embryo adoption remains a disputed question among Catholic theologians.
Resources
- Pre-order Dr. Alexander’s book, Frozen Embryos: A Catholic Moral Evaluation of Embryo Adoption, Cryopreservation, Rehydration, & Artificial Wombs
- Dignitas Personae
- NaProTechnology
- Saint Paul VI Institute
Keep giving God your fiat in the mess.
